The Hatchet

Seasons

2014–2025

Pick 'em titles

as published, ties included

Best Pick 'em finish

Pick 'em accuracy

63.7%

1617 of 2537 graded

Finishes

Season	Pool	Finish	Total
2025	Pick 'em	11 of 40	175
2025	Survival	16 of 41	4
2025	Underdog	38 of 41	6.5
2024	Pick 'em	11 of 48	192
2024	Survival	18 of 50	0
2024	Underdog	47 of 50	6.5
2023	Pick 'em	11 of 48	174
2023	Survival	9 of 49	6
2023	Underdog	45 of 49	6
2022	Pick 'em	43 of 46	148
2022	Survival	17 of 46	0
2022	Underdog	39 of 47	11.5
2021	Pick 'em	45 of 45	119
2021	Survival	24 of 44	7
2021	Underdog	19 of 44	38.5
2019	Pick 'em	24 of 45	158
2019	Survival	24 of 45	3
2019	Underdog	42 of 45	13.5
2018	Pick 'em	25 of 46	157
2018	Survival	4 of 46	2
2018	Underdog	25 of 47	20.5
2017	Pick 'em	23 of 47	163
2017	Survival	29 of 47	2
2017	Underdog	37 of 47	14.5
2015	Pick 'em	1 of 42	169
2015	Survival	4 of 42	1
2015	Underdog	5 of 42	48
2014	Pick 'em	7 of 36	162

20%

40%

60%

80%

56.9%

70.6%

2014201520172018201920212022202320242025

Share of graded Pick 'em picks that were right, by season.

Season	Graded	Right	Accuracy
2025	270	175	64.8%
2024	272	192	70.6%
2023	272	174	64.0%
2022	253	148	58.5%
2021	209	119	56.9%
2019	256	158	61.7%
2018	256	157	61.3%
2017	253	163	64.4%
2015	256	169	66.0%
2014	240	162	67.5%

Team	Picked	Won	Lost
Denver Broncos	134	74	60
Kansas City Chiefs	120	87	33
Green Bay Packers	117	80	37
Baltimore Ravens	114	79	35
Seattle Seahawks	110	72	38
New England Patriots	107	80	27
Philadelphia Eagles	105	71	34
Dallas Cowboys	102	70	32
San Francisco 49ers	102	66	36
Buffalo Bills	96	65	31

Teams are named as they were at the time, so a relocated franchise appears under each name.